Zach stepped out of his regular clothes and looked across the large bedroom, which was decorated in classic, wooden furniture. His live-in boyfriend of a year, Kevin, paused, staring at the police uniforms hung on the closet door. The unease in Kevin’s dark brown eyes made Zach wonder if tonight was a mistake. He loved Kevin, no doubt. The alpha man with muscles and dark brown hair had Zach from word one the day they met.
Denying that Zach had a lust for women would be a lie as well. His best friend since college was the one woman that his body still hummed for, even with Kevin in his life. Tonight they’d see if there was a chance.
“You’re not getting cold feet?” Zach didn’t mind staring at Kevin’s hard, naked body. The defined muscles trailed down his chest to stomach, ass, and legs. However, they had a window of time in which to execute their plan and too much stalling would ruin it.
Kevin frowned. “No, it’s one night. Abby is always teasing us about a three-way. I know you’re into that. I’ve just never tried anything with a woman before. I don’t want to ruin your fun.”
A knot started to form in Zach’s stomach. “Hey, listen, I’m not doing anything without you. Don’t get ahead of things. You’re type A, a hardcore planner. I know that. But remember Abby talks wild about a lot of stuff and she never does half of it. She’s always afraid she’ll get caught. She might freeze up or freak out at the actual prospect of a night with both of us.”
Shaking his head, Kevin checked his watch. “She’ll do it. I’ve ridden with her. She speeds like a demon so long as she thinks she won’t get caught. She’ll do it as long as she won’t get into any trouble.”
Zach nodded. “Because she trusts and loves both of us. I’ve known her longer, but that doesn’t mean she wants me more. She never tried to sleep with me until I started dating you. You get hit on more than I do.”
“I want a solid relationship, not to get hit on. Abby is different, but maybe this isn’t the best way to approach her fantasy. You and your Halloween pranks. This definitely tops what I’ve heard.” Kevin rolled his eyes.
“Come on, it’s perfect. I saw her costume. She never goes out slutty like that for a party. It’s too easy.” Cop uniforms were easy enough to buy, and he’d borrowed a friend’s old squad car. Bought from a police auction, it had the spotlight and Zach’s friend had restored the siren.
“She is paranoid. Dressed like that it’ll make it worse for her to get caught by an authority figure.” Kevin grinned just a bit.
“Exactly. You said cop was a role you always wanted to play in the bedroom. This way you’re in control. She’s in our custody. If you really don’t want to do something, you’re the one giving the orders, officer.” Zach slid up behind Kevin and wrapped his arms around Kevin’s broad chest.
“When I told you about that fantasy, I meant for you to be my prisoner.”
“Well, you know I’ll do anything. I’ll be the good cop, and you’ll be the bad cop. No reason you can’t be tough on Abby and me. You had those dreams about her anyway. I really think you need to try it with a girl.” Zach kissed his lover’s shoulder.
Kevin’s lips tugged into a slight smile. “Those dreams were weird. You were there.”
“Hell yeah. You don’t get to cheat even in your dreams.” Zach turned Kevin so they faced each other. “I know we’re not twenty-two. So we’re thirty-four. It’s never too late to experiment. Gay is one thing; bi is a bit trickier to manage. I had some relationships with women, but I’m not trying to change you. I think you’ll like it though.”
“If I don’t?” Kevin bristled.
“Then it’s one night we tried to fulfill a fantasy for a friend while doing some role-playing. It’ll be over. I’m not going to lose you over anything. Just try and enjoy it openly. Let down that tough cop ‘gay guy’ attitude and give pussy a try.” Zach pushed Kevin down to the bed and felt his lover’s cock respond.
“I love Abby like a friend. The dreams were intense, but I never thought of her like that. You know it’s just her nonstop suggestions. I’ve never even kissed a girl. I don’t want to ruin a relationship or a friendship in order to test-drive a woman.”
“That’s why Halloween is perfect. We do the costume thing, and if it doesn’t fly, we write it off as a goofy, role-playing, kinky night. It’ll make the surprise part so much better. No build up or tension…although you’re getting a bit tense.” Zach kissed Kevin’s neck to soothe him.
Kevin tilted his head down for more. “Have you ever shared a girl, or was it all one-on-one?”
Zach smiled. Kevin was curious, but the tough guy in him didn’t want to look foolish or feel awkward with something he’d never done. “The first time with a girl was in college. My roommate had a wild girlfriend who apparently had done a three-way with another girl for his birthday. She wanted equal time on her birthday, two guys.”
“He asked you?”
Zach licked along Kevin’s collarbone and Adam’s apple as his cock grew hard. “He was a bit curious. I knew that much. He let me catch him jerking off. The first time I backed out, but the second time he caught my eye, I sat down and watched.”
“I did that with guys in junior high.” Kevin laughed.
“Me too, but this guy never moved on with guys from there, at least that I know of. He watched me jerk off a few times but never made a move. Then all of a sudden, he wanted me to share his girlfriend. He was a hot guy, and she was very sexual, so I said yes.”
“It felt natural?”
“Odd at first. I dated guys in high school. Didn’t know how to be with a girl. Seemed awkward at first.” Zach nipped at Kevin’s ear as he felt the hard body of his lover. The muscled form was his first lust. “But it was arousing. She felt so firm and soft. It’s different.”
“Did you do anything with the guy in front of her?”
“She wanted us to, but he shied away from it. I didn’t want to push it. I had to live with the guy. But I thought about pinning him and blowing him. The feel of his cock inside of her, through her body, it was indescribable. I fucked pussy for the first time ever. Wet and eager, she was really amazing, but when he entered…” Zach rested his head on Kevin’s shoulder.
“Tight?” Kevin’s voice went husky.
“So tight. I could feel her body throbbing and his cock reacting as well, all inside. He was as big as me, so it was perfect.” Zach rubbed his erection against Kevin’s bare skin. “We were so horny it didn’t last long, but I swear she came three times before we were done.”
“Quite a way to end the night.” Kevin’s hands slid around to Zach’s ass.
Zach smiled and looked Kevin in the eye. “That was just the start. We didn’t get much sleep. We repeated the fun a few times before they broke up.”
“With them, yes. We got our naked thrills, but it wasn’t a real relationship. I tried dating a girl without a guy in the mix, and it didn’t seem to work. I needed men more.”
Kevin tensed. “Was that girl Abby?”
Shoving Kevin onto his back on the bed, Zach laid down next to him. “No, I never dated or slept with her. Not even a kiss. Is that part of this reluctance?”
“It’s not reluctance. There’s no problem. I’m just curious.”
Kevin had never asked him about his past with Abby. Zach had told him they were best friends and saw no need to elaborate. There was nothing more to tell. Clearly Kevin had been thinking all variations. “If I’d dated Abby, I’d have told you she was an ex -- not just a friend. She’s hot, smart, and fun, but I never thought she’d go for it.”
“Another guy? She’s been bugging us since I’ve known her.”
“She’s a goody-two-shoes. She teased frat boys like it was an Olympic sport, and yet never got wild and drunk with them like a lot of the girls. You’re the first of my boyfriends she ever commented on. She’s got it bad for you.” An ego stroke wouldn’t hurt Kevin, and Zach knew it.
Kevin leaned back and stared. “You’re in love with her.”
Fear gripped Zach as he let go of Kevin and took a deep breath. “I love you. What Abby and I have is a deep and complex friendship.” Lying was pointless. “If I could have my way, I’d keep you both. I know it’s a long shot, but tonight’s my fantasy too.”
Kevin kissed Zach hard, and Zach relaxed a bit. His hand roamed over Kevin’s hard form to find his cock still pulsing for attention. The idea of Kevin fucking Abby, of Abby blowing Kevin, had filled Zach’s dreams for so long. He couldn’t deny the need any longer, but he wouldn’t let it ruin their relationship. “I love you,” Zach repeated. “I’ll never give you up.”
Suddenly Kevin pulled Zach’s hand away and pinned Zach’s shoulders to the bed. Tonight would be full of surprises, but if Kevin changed his mind before they even got started, it’d be ruined.